Timothy Cavanagh and Michael Sorich of Cavanagh Sorich Law Group worked for a decade to secure a verdict for a man rendered quadriplegic after a crash on a Chicago motorway.

Timothy Cavanagh and Michael Sorich of Cavanagh Sorich Law Group worked for a decade to secure a verdict for a man rendered quadriplegic after a crash on a Chicago motorway.

March 25, 2016. A violent crash in a construction zone. A flipped limousine. Bright lights. Crushing pain. Lives changed forever, in an instant.

That morning, Wisconsin couple Rob Rosá and Michael Johnson were riding in a limousine from Madison, Wisconsin to O’Hare International Airport. They were driving along a highway that was undergoing construction as part of Move Illinois, the Illinois State Toll Highway Authority’s $14B construction project. Suddenly, and with little warning, there was a lane shift on the roadway. The driver ran into an attenuator (crash cushion), and the limousine flipped. One passenger died, and Rosá was airlifted to the hospital, where doctors confirmed that he’d been rendered quadriplegic.

Just days later, Rosá and Johnson would meet Chicago plaintiffs’ personal injury powerhouse Timothy Cavanagh in the hospital. Over the next decade, Cavanagh and co-lead trial counsel Michael Sorich – as well as partners Christopher Dietmann and Jason Kroot – would wade through nearly half a million documents, take more than 200 depositions and head to the 3rd Circuit Appellate Court and Supreme Court in an effort to hold the Tollway accountable.

Finally, on Oct. 9, 2025, the lawyers won a $104.6M jury verdict for Rosá – the largest verdict for a road construction case in Illinois history.

“It was a lot of heartbreak, tears and hard work,” Cavanagh says. “But ultimately, we have been vindicated, and Rob can get the best medical care.”

The result comes at an exciting time for the firm, Cavanagh Sorich Law Group. Of the nearly one billion dollars they’ve secured for their clients since the firm’s founding, $220M was recovered between 2023 and 2025 alone. At the same time, in June of last year, Cavanagh was appointed President of the Illinois Trial Lawyers Association (ITLA) – guiding not only his firm, but the broader Illinois legal community, to success.

These wins are reflective of the urgency, hard work and compassion behind the lawyering at Cavanagh Sorich – of the grit and fire that fuel every case.

INVESTIGATION AND DISCOVERY

When Cavanagh began working on the case, Rosá was in a coma in the intensive care unit at Lutheran General Hospital, a tier one trauma center in Chicago. Immediately, Cavanagh filed suit – initially against the limousine driver, the limousine company and construction companies. It was just a few weeks later that Cavanagh’s now-name partner, Sorich, joined the firm, and the case.

Cavanagh Sorich’s approach prioritizes aggressive, out-in-front legal strategy. “We’re not sitting around; we’re taking action in cases very early on,” says Sorich. “When we get involved in a case, we’re filing suit, we’re getting that protective order, we’re getting the documents.”

Together, the team worked to investigate and preserve evidence early, including documenting Rosá’s experience in the hospital and afterwards. Cavanagh hired a company called Evidence Video to record Rosá and Johnson’s daily life.

Over the following years, the company would return nine times to record more than 10 hours of day-in-the-life footage – going from the hospital stay, to the couple’s home, to physical therapy sessions. The footage documented Rosá’s need for constant care.

While Mikey Johnson initially tried to go back to work, “He realized he could not do it. The stress was immeasurable. He knew he had to be around,” says Cavanagh. “So then they had the added financial stress of Mikey’s lost income.”

Without the finances for home health care, both Johnson and a family friend left their jobs in order to care for Rosá, who needed 24/7 care as a result of his injuries. Johnson was by his husband’s side every moment.

“So many friends testified about how Mikey really stepped up to be there for Rob," Cavanagh says. “I’ve seen a lot of significant relationships in my life. This one is right up there.”

As the case progressed, Cavanagh, Sorich and team realized just how massive the road construction project was. It spanned more than 25 miles and required complicated oversight. While they settled with other defendants for $66M, the Illinois Tollway, who owned the highway on which the crash occurred, continued pushing back. Undeterred, the team continued digging.

So many friends testified about how Mikey really stepped up to be there for Rob.

The case against the Tollway eventually broke down into two theories or claims: the design case and the construction, or signage, case.

For the design case, the initial designs for the roadway planned for a continuous median barrier wall. Without warning or explanation, the lawyers say, those plans changed. Instead of a continuous barrier wall, there was a gap in the wall where they placed an attenuator on the blunt end of a concrete median barrier. “That crash cushion essentially acted as a spear pointing to oncoming traffic,” Sorich says.

In court, the lawyers hired a leading expert on barrier walls out of Texas A&M University, who Cavanagh had flown personally to meet.

“We were able to show the jury crash testing of vehicles hitting median barrier walls at different speeds and say, ‘Look, ladies and gentlemen. Had they put a continuous median barrier, this is how a vehicle would have acted and redirected back into traffic – and not caused those catastrophic injuries,’” says Cavanagh.

“There’s nothing more powerful than that,” he adds.

The lawyers argued that the Tollway should have known the details of the design, but what struck them most was the lack of explanation for the change.

“The Tollway was intimately involved in the design. They were at the meeting when these plans changed,” Sorich says. “When you’re involved in every phase of design and construction, you can’t just say, ‘I don’t know.’”

“If you’re going to be the owner of a tollway that brings in billions of dollars a year and your primary job is to make sure that tollway’s safe, and you’re going to be involved in meetings, do your damn job and pay attention,” Cavanagh says.

Then, there was the construction case. The Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD), along with some of the Tollway’s own policies, required that there be six warning signs in advance of the lane shift. Instead, there was only one.

“Because the topic of traffic control was discussed every week, we argued that the Tollway knew or should have known that these signs were missing,” says Cavanagh.

There could be no argument about the sign placement in court; in the discovery process, Cavanagh and team found that a company called EarthCam had been hired for the construction project to take a picture every 15 minutes on the job to put together a time lapse of the entire project. EarthCam had a camera directly pointed at the site of the crash – meaning that the lawyers had photographic evidence of the crash site every 15 minutes over two years.

“It was very effective being able to show the jury, ‘Here’s the Tollway’s own internal standards, policies and procedures, and this is what ultimately happened,’” says Cavanagh.

THE HOLDUPS

Despite rigorous preparation and an aggressive discovery process, the case was nearly derailed multiple times over the years, with several trial dates that never came to pass. After multiple delays due to Covid, the lawyers were up in the appellate court twice and the state Supreme Court once on two primary issues.

The first dispute was venue. The crash took place around a quarter mile outside the Cook County border, so the defendants originally asserted that the case had to be brought in neighboring Kane County. After two years of fighting the issue, the team successfully convinced a judge that because many of the defendants were Cook County contractors, that was the appropriate venue.

It was very effective being able to show the jury, ‘Here’s the Tollway’s own internal standards, policies and procedures, and this is what ultimately happened.'

But then came the case’s most crushing blow. After litigating the venue issue and going through more than 100 depositions, a full five years after the crash, another judge granted summary judgement and threw the case out of court. The judge ruled that the limousine driver’s failure to negotiate the curve in the lane shift was the sole proximate cause of the crash.

“That was a very disappointing day. I’ll never forget it,” Cavanagh says. “I remember coming back from court and talking to my entire team. We were disappointed but resolved to get the ruling reversed.”

“I knew I had a very good case,” he continues. “Even though the limo driver had the bulk of the fault, there’s no doubt about it, the Tollway and these construction and engineering companies dropped the ball.”

The attorneys appealed to the Illinois Appellate Court and the ruling was reversed in a 3-0 opinion. The defendants sought an appeal in the Illinois Supreme Court which delayed the case for another year. Ultimately the Supreme Court declined to get involved. That was in November 2024; less than a year later, they’d be walking away from a three-week trial with a nine-figure verdict.

DELIVERING JUSTICE

The decade of pushing was worth it. Now, Rosá will be able to receive the care he needs; he and his husband will have the financial security so that life can become closer to how it was before the crash.

When the verdict was read, every member of the jury came out to greet Rosá, Cavanagh remembers. They offered him handshakes and hugs; one woman even put her hand on his head and prayed for him.

“You don’t see that in every case,” says Cavanagh.

Sorich says the result also sends a message to the Tollway and other entities managing highway systems that they have an obligation to motorists to provide a safe mode of travel.

“It highlights the fact that the failure to implement safer alternative options, even when it’s pursuant to their policies and procedures, can have catastrophic results,” he adds.

The Rosá case is far from the firm’s only recent success. In November of 2024, Cavanagh, Sorich, and then-associate Dietmann secured a $50M settlement for a railway worker who was injured on the job. The man suffered catastrophic injuries after a fall from a reach stacker crane, resulting in the amputation of one leg and the loss of function of the other, along with the removal of portions of his pelvis, spleen, bladder and rectum. In all, he endured more than 30 surgeries and $7M in medical expenses. Cavanagh attended a site inspection and witnessed the “sheer magnitude of the machinery,” including the six-foot-tall wheels that caused the catastrophe.

The failure to implement safer alternative options, even when it’s pursuant to their policies and procedures, can have catastrophic results.

Then, in a three-week span in 2023, the team secured two more eight-figure results. First, Cavanagh and Sorich obtained a $27M settlement on behalf of the families of two young adults who were killed in a semi-tractor trailer crash. Then, Cavanagh, Sorich and Dietmann secured an $11.1M product liability settlement for a 25-year-old man who lost all five fingers on one hand as a result of an unguarded pinch point.

The partners credit each other for their successes.

“As a team, we really gel and feed off one another,” says Sorich. Looking at the Rosá trial, for example, he says, “We were in the office 15 hours a day every day, and it was so much of a collaborative approach.”

LEADERSHIP IN THE COURTS AND BEYOND

Building and cultivating a thriving team requires exceptional leadership. As founding partner, Cavanagh has provided that guidance in his firm and in the broader legal community.

Cavanagh’s decades of service to clients and the profession were recognized in June 2025, when he was appointed President of ITLA.

“It’s a huge honor,” says Cavanagh. “I’ve been a member of ITLA since the day I started at Phil Corboy’s office, which was March 16, 1992.”

As a result, mentorship and education are core tenants of his presidency, including “the best trial lawyer seminars for personal injury lawyers of any organization in the country,” he says. He is also actively involved in lobbying and legislation, including in a new toxic tort statute, SB 328. The bill, which passed in May of 2025, extends Illinois courts’ jurisdiction in cases involving out-of-state corporations.

Reflecting upon his leadership style, “I’m always accessible; always there. I think I’m relatively easygoing, but there’s an intensity behind me that I think is probably not always apparent,” Cavanagh muses. “I’m incredibly, incredibly competitive.”

To that end, asked about how he handles cases that stretch on as long as the Rosá case did, Cavanagh says, “Your reward for doing well in this job is that you’re going to have to work harder on other cases. When you win significant cases, you’re going to get other significant cases.”

If the firm’s recent track record is any indication, Cavanagh and team will be prepared for a lot of hard work in the years to come.